Why DIY Marketing Is Costing Financial Advisors More Than They Realize

Think DIY marketing is saving you money? Think again. AcquireUp’s CEO Greg Bogich unpacks why “figuring it out” yourself often costs more than just your time—from opportunity cost to missed leads.

Graphic image that reads "Bogich Briefing"

BY GREG BOGICH

Last week I had one of those “I’ve got this” moments that lasted… about sixteen minutes.

It started with a drip. Not a full-on leakjust a steady, annoying drip from my kitchen faucet.  

I confidently told myself (and, regrettably, my wife), “No need to call a plumber—how hard can it be?” Armed with one quick YouTube tutorial, I rolled up my sleeves, grabbed my toolbox, and got to work.

What followed was a masterclass in overconfidence (because that sounds better than ineptitude).

An hour later, the faucet was disassembled, the kitchen floor was soaked with 15 gallons of water, and my new YouTube search was: “How to shut off the water to your house?”—this time with a lot less confidence and a lot more urgency.

That little project ended with me calling a plumber, mopping up a small lake off the kitchen floor, and insisting to my wife that the first YouTube video was “stupid” and that the creator was “an idiot.” She wasn’t convinced.

The same thing happens in marketing—especially for financial advisors. If I had a dollar for every advisor who’s said, “I’ll just handle marketing myself,” I could start a hedge fund.

To be fair, it does sound like a good idea. You’re smart. You’re resourceful. You built your business from the ground up. So why wouldn’t you be able to figure out a direct mail campaign?  How hard can it be?  

And maybe you can do it yourself… but should you?

The Thing About “DIY”

DIY might seem cheap, but it usually comes with a significant cost. It may not be dollars—it might be your time, focus, or, most importantly, opportunity cost.  

You’re writing copy and trying to learn Meta Business Suite, when you should be meeting with clients and closing new business. Is that really the best use of your time?

DIY Marketing’s Greatest Hits:

  • The “One and Done” Campaign

You send one email or run one seminar and expect the leads to pour in like Black Friday. Spoiler: they won't.

  • The “Spray and Pray”

You boost a post to anyone who likes “money” or “finance” and get clicks from hundreds of bots and a dozen new high school graduates.

  • The Cold Start

You launch a campaign to a list of contacts you haven’t spoken to in a year or two. It’s the marketing equivalent of texting an ex “hey” and expecting them to say, “I’ve been waiting for this!”

  • The Copy-Paste Trap

You “borrow” someone else’s content or repurpose a generic email from a competitor.  It sounds safe and familiar—and illegal.

  • The Vanishing Follow-Up

You host an event or get a lead, then... crickets. Life gets busy, and the follow-up isn’t timely.  And by the time you do reach out, they forgot why they even reached out in the first place.

Why Expertise Matters

Marketing professionals do this every day. They know the platforms, the data, the targeting, and what actually works. They’ve tested landing pages, optimized outreach, and tracked lead quality across hundreds (or even thousands) of campaigns.

More importantly, they help you avoid wasting your time and money on things that don’t work.

You wouldn’t advise your clients to DIY their financial plan using an excel spreadsheet and their gut instincts. So why DIY your growth engine?

Good Marketing Isn’t Just “Running Ads”

It’s a system. A strategy. A repeatable, measurable process that:

  • Attracts the right people
  • Moves them through a journey
  • Builds trust
  • Creates conversion opportunities
  • Follows up consistently
  • Nurtures long-term relationships

And let’s be honest—most advisors didn’t become advisors because they’re dying to master click-through rates or subject line A/B tests.

The Hidden Cost of “Figure It Out Later”

The biggest risk of DIY marketing isn’t the money you spend—it’s the money you never make because of:

  • The leads that didn’t convert when your form was broken.
  • The prospects who ghosted because they didn’t get a follow-up.
  • The months when no campaigns ran because you got too busy.
  • Your pipeline was quite instead of full

It’s not dramatic. It’s just a slow steady erosion.

Just Because You Can Doesn’t Mean You Should

Could you manage your own marketing? Probably.

You could also cut your own hair, build your own deck, or fix your own leaky faucet. But is that how you want to spend your time—or build your brand?  More importantly, is it the best way to spend your time?

If growth is your goal, invest in the systems, support, and expertise that allow you to do what you do best: build relationships, serve your clients, and scale your business.  At least that’s this “plumber’s” perspective.

FAQs

Need more details? We’re here to help. Learn about our services, technology, and how we support financial professionals.

Get Answers
How can I balance DIY marketing with professional help?

Many advisors combine DIY efforts for quick tests or small tasks with outsourced expertise for strategy, complex campaigns, and optimization to maximize efficiency and results.

What are the biggest risks of doing my own marketing?

Common risks include broken lead capture forms, lack of timely follow-up, running ineffective or inconsistent campaigns, and losing valuable prospects due to missed opportunities—all of which can stall your business growth.

Can DIY marketing deliver results for financial advisors?

Yes, with the right knowledge and consistent effort, DIY marketing can produce leads. However, scaling growth and maintaining long-term results often require professional systems and support.

What challenges do financial advisors face with DIY marketing?

Common challenges include time constraints, lack of marketing expertise, inconsistent execution, and difficulty measuring and optimizing campaigns effectively.

How can I decide whether to DIY or hire marketing help?

Consider your available time, marketing skills, budget, growth goals, and whether you want to focus on client relationships versus campaign management.

You might also like